Navy News Make-'A'-Mends
13 May 2008
Search Navy News Online
Sign Up for our Newsletter
 
1. REAL ENGAGEMENTS/INCIDENTS   08.02.01 16:48

Since life and entertainment tend to represent opposite experiences, the concept of 'real' needs to be understood in this case as approximate only. Here are famous battles, exploits and so on, rendered with at least some degree of faithfulness to their reality, so far as that is ascertainable, but also, invariably, with more or less significant concessions to perceived box office requirements.

A-B | C-G | H-R | S-T | U-Z
 
A-B
 
Above Us the Waves (GB, 1954, 99 mins)
The attack (September 1943) by British midget submarines on the Tirpitz while she was anchored in a Norwegian fjord. With John Mills, John Gregson, James Robertson Justice. Dir Ralph Thomas
Saving Private Ryan
The Americanisation of Emily (US, 1964, 117 mins)

Satirical account of political manoeuvrings in the US Navy upper echelons before and during the Normandy invasion. (This seems to be the only film relating to D-Day that is primarily naval in focus. The Longest Day (1962) is the most detailed re-enactment of the landings.

Other titles - D-Day the Sixth of June (1956), Up From the Beach (1965), Overlord (1975) and Saving Private Ryan (1998) - are almost entirely army-oriented.) With James Garner, Julie Andrews, James Coburn. Dir Arthur Hiller

The Angry Sea (aka Ikari no Umi) (Japan, 1944, 90 mins)
A Japanese perspective on the London Naval Disarmament Conference of November 1934, in which Britain and America scheme to limit Japanese naval progress. Dir Tadashi Imai
The Battle of the Japan Sea (aka Nihonkai Daikaisen) (Japan, 1969, 128 mins)
Spectacular account of the battle of the Tsushima Straits of 1905, in which the Japanese admiral Togo destroyed the Russian fleet opposing him. With Toshiro Mifune. Dir SeijiMaruyama
For Freedom
Battleship Potemkin (aka Bronenosets Potyemkin) (USSR, 1925, 65 mins)
Silent Soviet classic, concerning the mutiny of the Black Sea fleet during the abortive 1905 revolution. With A Antonov, V Barski, G Alexandrov. Dir SM Eisenstein
The Battle of Jutland (GB, 1921, 30 mins)
The first of a number of features made by British Instructional Films about major land and sea engagements of WW1, using archive material, animated maps and specially shot scenes. This describes the only occasion (May 1916) when two modern battle fleets engaged one another in European waters. Dir. H.Bruce Woolfe
For Freedom
The Battle of the River Plate (aka Pursuit of the Graf Spee) (GB, 1956, 117 mins)
An account of the first major naval action of WW2 - the fight between the pocket battleship Graf Spee (played by the US heavy cruiser Salem) and HMS Ajax (played by HMS Sheffield), HMNZS Achilles (played by INS Delhi) and HMS Exeter (played by HMS Jamaica); HMS Cumberland, also involved, plays herself. With Peter Finch, Anthony Quayle, John Gregson. Dir Michael Powell/Emeric Pressburger
The Battles of Coronel and the Falkland Islands (GB, 1927, 115 mins)
Another of the British Instructional features, this deals with the battle of Coronel (November1914: German victory, sinking of HMS Good Hope and Monmouth) and its sequel off the Falklands (December 1914: British victory, sinking of the Scharnhorst, Gneisenau and others.) Dir. Walter Summers
 
C-G
 
Channel Incident (GB, 1940, 15 mins)
Woman with motorboat joins impromptu armada for the Dunkirk evacuation. With Peggy Ashcroft, Robert Newton, Gordon Harker. Dir Anthony Asquith
Cockleshell Heroes (GB, 1955, 98 mins)
Story of how a unit of Marines used kayaks to infiltrate Bordeaux harbour and destroy German shipping with limpet mines. With Trevor Howard, Jose Ferrer, Anthony Newley. Dir Jose Ferrer
The Court-Martial of Billy Mitchell (aka One Man Mutiny) (US, 1955, 100 mins)
Mitchell was a US Army Air Force brigadier, whose aggressive championing of aerial warfare in the 1920s led to him being dismissed from the service. Of naval interest for Mitchell's demonstration of the vulnerability of capital ships and his prediction of the attack on Pearl Harbour. With Gary Cooper, Rod Steiger, Charles Bickford. Dir Otto Preminger
Dunkirk (GB, 1958, 134 mins)
The fortunes of an army platoon trying to reach the Dunkirk beaches; and the organizing of the rescue flotilla, including civilian small boats. (A French account - Weekend at Dunkirk,1965 - is mainly concerned with the French army.) With John Mills, Bernard Lee, Richard Attenborough. Dir Leslie Norman
For Freedom
For Freedom (GB, 1940, 84 mins)
A potted history of the events leading up to the war is followed by a re-enactment of the battle of the River Plate, and its sequel, the boarding of the supply ship Altmark. Made immediately after the events, and featuring some of the personnel who took part. With Will Fyffe, Albert Lieven, Anthony Hulme. Dir Maurice Elvey/Castleton Knight
The Gallant Hours (US, 1960, 116 mins)
Admiral W. Halsey recalls his WW2 experiences, particularly the sea battle off Guadalcanal, November 1942. With James Cagney, Dennis Weaver, Richard Jaeckel. Dir. Robert Montgomery
Gift Horse (aka Glory at Sea) (GB, 1952, 100 mins)
Fictionalised story of one of the fifty over-age ships transferred from the USA to Britain in1940; climax is the raid on St Nazaire, March 1942. With Trevor Howard, Richard Attenborough, James Donald. Dir Compton Bennett
 
H-R
 
Human Torpedoes (aka I Sette dell' Orsa Maggiore) (Italy, 1953, 102 mins)
Recounts an assault by an Italian underwater team on British warships in Alexandria harbour; several of the personnel involved appear in the film. (Based on the same action depicted in The Valiant - see below.) With Paul Cressoy, Tino Carraro, Paul Mulle. Dir Duilio Coletti If We Go To Sea (aka Umi Yukuba) (Japan, 1943, 90 mins) Dramatised account of the creation of the Japanese navy as a fighting force in the years before the outbreak of war. Dir Masanori Igayama
Inchon (US, 1982, 105 mins)
Korea, September 1950; the amphibious landing at Inchon (mostly unopposed) and the land fighting that followed. With Laurence Olivier, Ben Gazzara, Richard Roundtree. Dir Terence Young
The Man Who Never Was (GB, 1955, 103 mins)
Plot hatched by the Admiralty to mislead the enemy about the forthcoming Sicily landings, by planting false information on a drowned corpse. With Clifton Webb, Robert Flemyng, Stephen Boyd. Dir. Ronald Neame
Midway
Midway (aka Battle of Midway)
(US, 1976, 132 mins) Describes the course of the great naval battle of June 1942, intermingled with the personal stories of some of the people involved. With Charlton Heston, Henry Fonda, James Coburn. Dir Jack Smight
Mission of the Shark (US, 1991, 100 mins)
The torpedoing of the USS Indianapolis in 1945, and the subsequent ordeal of the survivors in the water. With Stacy Keach, Richard Thomas, Don Harvey. Dir Robert Iscove
Okinawa (US, 1952, 67 mins)
Set on a destroyer taking part in the naval operations supporting the invasion of Okinawa, April 1945; includes much newsreel material. With Pat O'Brien, Cameron Mitchell, Richard Denning. Dir. Leigh Jason
PT 109 (US, 1963, 140 mins)
The adventures of president-to-be John F Kennedy, skipper of a PT boat which is sunk by a Japanese destroyer. With Cliff Robertson, Robert Culp, Robert Blake. Dir. Leslie Martinson
 
S-T
 
San Demetrio, London (GB, 1943, 104 mins)
An incident from the battle of the Atlantic: the crew of a torpedoed tanker first abandon her then, finding her still afloat after several days, reboard her and manage to steer her home to the Clyde. "From factual material by F Tennyson Jesse". With Walter Fitzgerald, Ralph Michael, Frederick Piper. Dir Charles Frend
The Silent Enemy (GB, 1958, 92 mins)
The wartime exploits of Lionel Crabb, i/c the diving team based on Gibraltar, 1941.(Commander Crabb RNVR disappeared under mysterious circumstances in April 1956,apparently while diving near some visiting Soviet warships in Portsmouth harbour - a sensational news story in its day, and evidently the spur for the production of this picture.)With Laurence Harvey, Michael Craig, John Clements. Dir William Fairchild
The Sinking of the Lusitania (US, 1918, 12 mins)
Technically extraordinary animated depiction of the sinking in 1915 of the liner Lusitania by the German sub U-20. Dir Winsor McCay
Sink the Bismarck! (GB, 1960, 97 mins)
An account of the Bismarck's breakout into the Atlantic in Spring 1941, its sinking of HMS Hood, and its eventual destruction. With Kenneth More, Carl Mohner, Michael Hordern. Dir Lewis Gilbert
The Story of Dr.Wassell (US, 1944, 140 mins)
Dr.Wassell was a US navy doctor who refused to abandon his patients, conducting them safely from Japanese-held Java to Australia. With Gary Cooper, Dennis O'Keefe, Laraine Day. Dir Cecil B DeMille
The Sullivans (aka The Fighting Sullivans) (US, 1944, 111 mins)
The Sullivans were five brothers from Waterloo, Iowa who all joined the navy and who were all killed together when the cruiser Juneau was sunk off Guadalcanal. With Edward Ryan, John Campbell, James Cardwell. Dir Lloyd Bacon
Tora! Tora! Tora!  
Tora! Tora! Tora! (US, 1970, 143 mins)
The Japanese bombing of the US Pacific Fleet at Pearl Harbour, December 1941. The first half describes from both Japanese and American perspectives the events leading up to the attack, the second half reproduces the attack itself. With Martin Balsam, So Yamamura. EG Marshall. Dir. Richard Fleischer. (nb. this action has also been featured in such melodramas as From Here to Eternity, 1953; In Harm's Way, 1965 - see Stories of the War at Sea, below; and Pearl, 1978. The scene in which the news of Pearl Harbour is first broken over the radio back in America is, of course, a recurring one in Hollywood WW2 movies. And the1953 anti-communist thriller Big Jim McLain includes a scene is which the hero, John Wayne, visits the wreck of the Arizona to vow "Never again..." See also December 7th in the Documentary section, below.)
 
U-Z
 
Under Ten Flags (aka Sotto Dieci Bandiere) (Italy/US, 1960, 92 mins)
The story of the German armed merchant ship Atlantis, which sank 22 Allied vessels before herself being disposed of by HMS Devonshire. (The hero-worshipping portrayal of the Atlantis's captain - Bernhard Rogge, a NATO admiral at the time the film was made -generated much controversy in the UK.) With Van Heflin, Charles Laughton, John Ericson. Dir Duilio Coletti
The Valiant (aka L'Affondamento della 'Valiant') (GB/Italy, 1961, 90 mins)
Anglo-Italian movie about an incident in WW2, when two Italian frogmen placed time-fused mines under the British battleship Valiant. (The film was shot on board an Italian cruiser reprieved from the scrap yard; see also Human Torpedoes, above.) With John Mills, Ettore Manni, Robert Shaw. Dir Roy Baker
Yangtse Incident (aka Battle Hell/Escape of the Amethyst) (GB, 1957, 113 mins)
Describes how the frigate Amethyst was detained by the Chinese in 1949 and how, after negotiations failed, she escaped under heavy fire to the open sea. HMS Amethyst is played by herself, the Yangtse is played by the river Orwell, in Suffolk. With Richard Todd, Donald Houston, Robert Urquhart. Dir Michael Anderson
Zeebrugge (aka The Attack on Zeebrugge) (GB, 1924, 70 mins/also abridged to 16 mins)
Another British Instructional re-enactment, this time of the attempt (April 1918) to block the submarine canal at Zeebrugge with five old cruisers filled with cement. Dir H Bruce Woolfe/AV Bramble
 
 
 
 
 
 
Top Stories
Of mouse and men
Return of the mighty sausage
Supa new vehicle for Green Berets
Civic duties for Severn
No revolution but evolution for the RFA
End of an eventful deployment
Dean’s damage put right by sailors
Somerset shines at Devon Regatta
Northumberland takes the fight to the terrorists
Puddin’ in an appearance on home turf